Correction (10 October 2026): an earlier version of this page listed places and details we could not stand behind. It has been rewritten from scratch: every place below was confirmed at two independent sources on 9 October 2026, and every price was copied from the page it was published on.
Short page. We could verify only four places in Brighton for cake and dessert, so that is all we list.
Two are shops whose names say cakes and pastries. Two are restaurants that print a dessert on the menu. We did not find a dedicated dessert bar.
Each place was checked against OpenStreetMap, its own site and the Australian Good Food Guide (AGFG). Prices appear only where a menu printed them.
The quick picks
| If you’re after | Head to | Order this | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Homemade cakes | Keith Homemade Cakes | see below | not printed here |
| Bread and pastries | House of Bread and Pastries | see below | not printed here |
| Chocolate cake with ice cream | Buffalo Boy | Belgium chocolate cake, vanilla ice cream | $14.50 |
| Tiramisu icecream dessert | Brighton Bay Pizza & Pasta | Tiramisu Icecream Dessert | $7 |
Keith Homemade Cakes — 46 Church Street, Brighton VIC 3186
Short and plain. Keith Homemade Cakes is at 46 Church Street, and its site lists open hours of 7am to 5pm Monday to Friday and 7am to 3pm Saturday. AGFG lists Child Friendly and Takeaway. We could not find a published cake price, and the site carries no recent date.
Order: Check the site or ring first, since we found no published cake list or price.
House of Bread and Pastries — 155 Martin Street, Brighton VIC 3186
House of Bread and Pastries is at 155 Martin Street. Its site lists 5:30am to 5:30pm Monday to Saturday, and 6am to 4pm Sunday. AGFG lists Takeaway. We copied no prices, and the site is undated, so confirm before you go.
Mess forecast: Unknown, because we found no published item list and will not guess.
Buffalo Boy — 279 Bay Street, Brighton VIC 3186
Buffalo Boy’s menu prints Belgium chocolate cake, vanilla ice cream at $14.50. That is the dessert line we copied. AGFG gives the address as 279 Bay Street, entered through the rear, and ticks Child Friendly, Vegan Options, Takeaway and Alfresco Dining.
On the menu (copied from buffaloboy.com.au/new-menu-2027-B.B-.pdf on 9 October 2026):
- Belgium chocolate cake, vanilla ice cream: $14.50
- Sweet potato fries, chilli mayo (v): $12.50
The build: Two parts on the menu line: Belgium chocolate cake and vanilla ice cream.
Brighton Bay Pizza & Pasta — 322 Bay Street, Brighton VIC 3186
The menu at Brighton Bay Pizza & Pasta prints Tiramisu Icecream Dessert at $7. Its site lists store hours of 5:00pm to 9:00pm Tuesday to Sunday, with Monday closed. AGFG lists Takeaway, Child Friendly and Vegan Options.
On the menu (copied from brightonbaypizza.com.au on 9 October 2026):
- Tiramisu Icecream Dessert: $7
- Garlic Bread: $6
- Garlic Bread With Cheese: $8
- Chicken Parmigiana: $25
Order: Start with the Tiramisu Icecream Dessert at $7, as the menu prints it.
Quick answers
Where can you buy cake in Brighton?
Two shops are on this page: Keith Homemade Cakes on Church Street and House of Bread and Pastries on Martin Street. Both list their hours on their own sites. We could not read cake prices at either.
Which Brighton restaurants print a dessert price?
Buffalo Boy’s menu prints Belgium chocolate cake, vanilla ice cream at $14.50. Brighton Bay Pizza & Pasta’s menu prints Tiramisu Icecream Dessert at $7.
Is there a dessert bar in Brighton?
We did not find a dedicated dessert bar among the places we could verify. The four on this page are two cake and pastry shops and two restaurants with a dessert on the menu.
What time do Brighton cake shops open?
Keith Homemade Cakes lists 7am on its own site from Monday to Saturday. House of Bread and Pastries lists 5:30am Monday to Saturday on its own site, and 6am on Sunday. Both are owner-published, so check before a special trip.
How we checked
We checked every place on this page against at least two independent sources on 9 October 2026: OpenStreetMap, the places’ own websites and the Australian Good Food Guide. Every price is copied exactly as printed on the page linked under Sources, on 9 October 2026. Menus, prices and opening hours change, so check with the venue before you go. The cover photo is illustrative, from Unsplash, and does not show any place on this page.
Seen something out of date? Email [email protected] with the page link and what has changed, and we will check it again.
Sources
- Keith Homemade Cakes: openstreetmap.org/1031065787, keithcakes.com.au, agfg.com.au/keith-homemade-cakes-36660
- House of Bread and Pastries: openstreetmap.org/7975385787, houseofbreadandpastries.com.au, agfg.com.au/house-of-bread-pastries-in-brighton
- Buffalo Boy: openstreetmap.org/6125963531, buffaloboy.com.au, agfg.com.au/buffalo-boy-49810, buffaloboy.com.au/new-menu-2027-B.B-.pdf
- Brighton Bay Pizza & Pasta: openstreetmap.org/6978758138, brightonbaypizza.com.au, agfg.com.au/martinellas-brighton-bay-pizza-137881
