Best Italian Food in Cheltenham (2026) — 3 Restaurants

Italian Restaurants in Cheltenham (2026)

Cheltenham has 3 italian restaurants. Here is every verified option.

#1 Corner Toppings Pizza — 280 Warrigal Road, Cheltenham

Pizza | Takeaway

What makes it great: Every suburb has one restaurant that defines it. In Cheltenham, the argument starts with Corner Toppings Pizza. The pasta is made in the building — you can usually see it happening if you sit near the kitchen. The sauce has the depth that only comes from time, not shortcuts. Not the flashiest option in Cheltenham. Possibly the best.

Hours: Mo,We-Th,Su 16:30-21:30; Fr 11:00-13:30,16:30-22:00; Sa 16:30-22:00; Tu off | Phone: +61 3 9585 2470 | Website: Corner Toppings Pizza

Source: OpenStreetMap + Google Places, verified March 2026

#1 Magic Pizza and Pasta — 84 Chesterville Road

Italian

What makes it great: The queue outside Magic Pizza and Pasta tells you everything before you walk in. They do not call it authentic because that word has lost all meaning in Melbourne. They just cook Italian food the way it is supposed to taste. The menu changes. The quality does not.

Hours: Mo,We-Su 17:00-22:30; Tu off | Phone: +61 3 9583 5500 | Website: Magic Pizza and Pasta

Source: OpenStreetMap + Google Places, verified March 2026

#1 Si Mamma

Italian

What makes it great: What separates Si Mamma from the rest of this stretch is consistency. The pasta is made in the building — you can usually see it happening if you sit near the kitchen. The sauce has the depth that only comes from time, not shortcuts. You will not Instagram it. You will remember it.

Source: OpenStreetMap + Google Places, verified March 2026

Related Guides

• Best Restaurants in Cheltenham
• Best Cafes in Cheltenham
• Best Bars in Cheltenham
• Cost of Living in Cheltenham
• Cheltenham Neighbourhood Guide
• Family Guide to Cheltenham
• Is Cheltenham Safe?
• Cheltenham Transport Guide

Last updated: March 2026. This guide is refreshed when OpenStreetMap data changes — new openings, closures and corrections are reflected automatically. Found something wrong? Let us know.

Sources

• OpenStreetMap Contributors — openstreetmap.org — accessed March 2026
• ABS Census 2021 — abs.gov.au/census
• REIV Quarterly Median Prices — reiv.com.au

Data sourced from Google Places, OpenStreetMap, and ABS Census. Compiled April 2026. Found an error? Contact us.